Guillermo del Toro, the visionary director known for his enchanting fantasy-horror films, takes a surprising turn in “Nightmare Alley,” abandoning the supernatural elements that defined his past works. However, fear not, for del Toro’s signature darkness remains intact, as he crafts a chilling tale of mind manipulation and moral decay.
The film introduces us to Stanton Carlisle, portrayed impeccably by Bradley Cooper, a charismatic drifter seeking a fresh start in a carnival. Amidst shocking ‘geek shows’ and secrets of mentalism, he falls for the enchanting Molly, portrayed by Rooney Mara. As the plot unfolds, Stan’s path collides with the sultry psychiatrist Dr Lilith Ritter, brought to life by the brilliant Cate Blanchett. Their enthralling high-stakes power struggle becomes the heart of the narrative, captivating the audience with each probing move and cunning scheme.
In true del Toro fashion, the film oozes with dreamlike and nightmarish atmospheres. From the blazing ruins of Stan’s past to the dark underbelly of the carnival, the director weaves a visually striking tapestry that immerses viewers in the unsettling world of deception.
The film’s dual-part structure mirrors a novel’s depth, allowing Cooper’s character to become the narrative’s compelling through-line. With a patient and linear approach, del Toro lets the story unfold gradually, keeping audiences on edge as the tension mounts. As the film crescendos to a bloody climax, the true extent of del Toro’s mastery is revealed.
While Cooper’s outstanding performance shines throughout, it is Cate Blanchett’s captivating portrayal of Dr Lilith Ritter that elevates the film’s intensity. Her character’s cat-and-mouse game with Stan creates electric scenes that are nothing short of enthralling.
Del Toro’s “Nightmare Alley” might not be a traditional spook show, but it is undoubtedly a dark carnival of exploitation, blending elements of paranoid noir, psychological thriller, and grifter tale. As the director stays true to his cinematic identity, the absence of supernatural beings does not dampen the film’s eerie and atmospheric nature.
In conclusion, “Nightmare Alley” is a mesmerizing descent into the depths of human darkness, offering an enveloping atmosphere, compelling characters, and the exquisite craftsmanship that defines del Toro’s work. While it may not surpass his greatest works, the film solidifies his position as a master storyteller, leaving audiences haunted and spellbound.
