The Scream franchise has had a rollercoaster of success, with the first two films being hailed as slasher movie classics. However, the magic seemed to wane after Scream 2 (1997), leaving fans hopeful for a return to form in “Scream VI” (2023). Directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett, the film starts promisingly, but unfortunately, it fails to sustain that momentum through to the end.
A Familiar Start with a New Twist
“Scream VI” opens with the typical Ghostface murder sequence that fans expect, but this time, it unfolds in New York City. Samara Weaving makes a memorable cameo as an associate professor of 20th Century slashers, setting the stage for a new cast of characters. While the initial kills are unsettling and effective, the film struggles to maintain this level of intensity.
Sisters Tara and Sam Carpenter
The story revolves around sisters Tara (Jenna Ortega) and Sam (Melissa Barrera). Tara wants to lead a normal life, while Sam grapples with her dark past, including killing one of the Ghostface killers in the previous film. Their lives become entangled with new characters, including survivors from the past films like Hayden Panettiere’s Kirby and Courteney Cox’s Gale Weathers.
Promising Performances and Tensions
The performances in “Scream VI” are a step up from the previous installment. Barrera delivers a strong performance, bringing depth to her haunted character. Jenna Ortega impresses as well, showcasing her talent once again. The interactions between the characters create tension, especially as they face the threat of the new Ghostface killer.
Lost Potential in the Climax
Despite its potential, “Scream VI” falls short in its climax. The killers’ motivations are abandoned in favor of a recycled revenge plot, diluting the menace Ghostface had built throughout the film. The movie’s attempts to explain the killers’ actions strip away the chilling mystery that made the franchise so captivating in the past.
Character Choices and Lack of Impact
Sam’s character arc presents another issue, as her disturbing acts of violence make her difficult to connect with emotionally. The film’s gutlessness in refusing to kill off certain characters diminishes the impact of the danger they face. As a result, the climax feels lackluster and fails to deliver the thrills that fans expect from a Scream movie.
A Mixed Direction for the Series
Critics have pointed out that “Scream VI” takes itself more seriously than its predecessors, losing some of the series’ trademark satirical edge. While this approach works in some aspects, it ultimately contributes to the film’s downfall. It is frustrating to see a movie with potential shoot itself in the foot with a lackluster conclusion.
Final Verdict: A Disappointing Return
In the end, “Scream VI” had the elements for a triumphant return to form, but its weaknesses in character choices and the lackluster climax overshadow the promising aspects. The film begins with nostalgic thrills, but it struggles to maintain its momentum, leaving audiences wanting more. Fans of the franchise may still find moments to enjoy, but overall, “Scream VI” falls short of living up to its iconic predecessors.
