1. Why It’s Overrated: The Plot Isn’t Unique While Attack on Titan is praised for its unconventional plot featuring titans and humanity on the brink of extinction, some argue that the storyline isn’t entirely original. Elements from other anime and manga series, like Blue Gender and Claymore, have influenced the narrative. Even inspirations from Godzilla and Gundam can be detected. While the titan premise is unique, the overall delivery and ending may not be as innovative as fans claim.
2. Why It’s Not Overrated: Great World-Building Despite criticism for unoriginality, Attack on Titan excels in world-building. The post-apocalyptic setting of humanity retreating behind walls to escape titans’ rampage was fascinating. As the story progressed, it revealed a deeper world, with countries thriving beyond the walls and the true nature of the titans. This revelation left fans intrigued and engaged in exploring the complex world of the series.
3. Why It’s Overrated: Slow Pacing at the Start One aspect that turned some fans away during the earlier episodes of Attack on Titan was the slow pacing. The first 24 episodes were criticized for being sluggish, with the series seemingly going through the motions before the major plot twists were unveiled. Though the pacing improved later on, some viewers were deterred by the slow build-up.
4. Why It’s Not Overrated: The Twists and Turns The gradual unveiling of plot twists and mysteries was one of Attack on Titan’s strengths. Fans were kept in the dark, unaware of the full titan mystery and humanity’s fate. The surprises were revealed gradually, keeping viewers invested and eager to learn more about the world and the titans. The series’ ability to keep its audience engaged was a testament to its storytelling prowess.
5. Why It’s Overrated: Can Be Too Violent Being a mature-themed anime, Attack on Titan features graphic and violent scenes, including titans devouring humans. While this might suit the intended audience, some found the violence excessive and off-putting. The excessively gory and bloody scenes may have deterred viewers with a weaker stomach.
6. Why It’s Not Overrated: The Characters Are Very Human Unlike typical anime protagonists who are either purely good or evil, Attack on Titan’s characters are refreshingly human. Each character is motivated by their interests and survival rather than solely fighting for the greater good. Their relatable stories and complex motivations make them more human and realistic, adding depth to the narrative.
7. Why It’s Overrated: Eren Pulled a Lelouch Critics pointed out that Eren’s actions in the final arc resembled a tactic used by Lelouch in Code Geass. Eren’s decision to commit mass genocide and become a villain to protect his friends mirrored Lelouch’s martyrdom to unite warring nations. Some felt this similarity made the ending unoriginal and a weaker conclusion.
8. Why It’s Not Overrated: There’s No True Bad Guy The complexity of Attack on Titan lies in its characters, with no clear-cut villains. Each antagonist, like Annie, Reiner, and Bertholdt, had human reasons for their actions. Even Eren, as the final arc’s antagonist, wasn’t inherently evil. The series offered multiple perspectives, showcasing the gray areas of each character’s motivations.
9. Why It’s Overrated: The Ending Didn’t Change Anything Although Eren’s actions led to a temporary period of peace, the world eventually returned to war and hatred between nations. Some viewers felt that the ending rendered Eren’s sacrifices meaningless, showing that the cycle of war and conflict continued unchanged.
10. Why It’s Not Overrated: It Mirrors the Reality of War Attack on Titan’s depiction of ongoing conflict and war between the Eldians and other nations is a reflection of real-world wars and animosities. The casualties of war, innocent lives affected, and never-ending hatred resonate with the harsh reality of conflicts around the world. This aspect of the series added depth and poignancy to its narrative.
In conclusion, Attack on Titan may have its share of overrated and underrated aspects, but its compelling world-building, intriguing plot twists, and nuanced characters have undoubtedly left a lasting impact on anime enthusiasts worldwide. While some critics point out its flaws, the series’ ability to mirror real-world complexities and engage its audience makes it a memorable and significant addition to the anime landscape.
